Back to the home page
Review: Farinelli's 2010
Where The Locals Eat Best Contemporary 2010
D&C 2008 Rochester’s Best Fine Dining Award
City Newspaper 2008 Best Romantic Restaurant Award
City Newspaper 2008 Best Wine List Award
D&C 2006 Rochester’s Best Fine Dining Award
City Newspaper 2006 Critics' Choice Award
D&C 2004 Rochester’s Best Fine Dining Award
City Newspaper 2004 Readers' Choice Award
City Newspaper 2004 Critics' Choice Award
New York Times Article 2001
New York Times Sidebar 2001
City Newspaper 2000 Readers' Choice Award
Rochester D&C Review 1999
Landmark Society Award 1999
AIA Award 1999
Fine dining has a new name: 2 Vine.

By Diana Louise Carter

Democrat and Chronical
Weekend Magazine
April 29, 1999

RATING: 10

Take key players from The Brasserie, Harry’s Bar & Grill and Rooney’s.  Mix with a tastefully rehabbed building.  Place in an up-and-coming cultural district. 

It’s a recipe for delight: Restaurant 2 Vine. 

Rochester’s newest fine-dining establishment could hold its own against anything in bigger cities.  Its prices match those found in big cities, too, but the portions and ingredients justify the costs.

This is a fancy restaurant, but steps have been taken to keep the place from seeming stuffy.  Customers are greeted by crates of apples in the vestibule.  Tablecloths are topped with white butcher paper.  Wine is served in straight sided juice glasses.  Bread comes in a paper wrapper.  And the serving staff have tablecloths tied around their waists for aprons.

All these trappings, through, belie the elegance of the food. 

Take this salad, for instance: mild, chopped Belgian endive mixed with cubes of ripe pear, candied walnuts and creamy, mellow Maytag blue cheese with a hint of lemon ($7).  This melange of textures and sweet-and-sour flavors could have been a lunch entree, but it also kick-started taste buds for a delightful dinner to follow.

Grilled sausages – two of the tastiest I’ve ever had – on escarole with lemon sauce ($8) was a hearty and satisfying appetizer, especially paired with hunks of a whole wheat baguette.

The chefs have a special talent for grilling.  Salmon ($17) was cooked perfectly _ no trace of transparency inside, but every bite was moist and flaky.  It came on a small bed of chopped fennel and tiny French lentils and was topped with crispy onions fried so delicately it wouldn’t be fair to call them common onion rings.

My pork chop ($16) was a special treat.  The thick, juicy chop was butterflied before grilling and served on top of a pool of seared escarole and a sweet sauce made from prunes that worked perfectly with the flavor of the pork.

Main dishes usually had no sides, which are ordered separately. Seared Garlic Spinach ($5) was good enough to make Popeye week in the knees, but the Smashed Herbed New Potatoes ($3) seemed overly dry.

The one entrée that disappointed was penne ($14) with white beans, celery, tomato and crushed red pepper.  It tasted good, and the flavors melded nicely, but it just wasn’t as exciting as the non-vegetarian dishes.

Two favorite desserts: crème brulee and maple ice cream (both $6).  The crème brulee was as good as the Brasserie’s, which sets the standard in town.  And the maple ice cream tasted like a frosty, solid version of maple syrup.

One of our servers was great, never missing an opportunity to refill our water glasses or make sure everything was going well.  On another, quieter night, a different waiter seemed distracted and made several errors which were quickly corrected.

None of these little problems marred our impression that to dine at 2 Vine is divine.

Restaurant 2 Vine:

Address: 24 Winthrop Str., in the city’s East End.

Phone: (585) 454-6020

Serving: Lunch on weekdays’ dinner Monday through Saturday.

Cuisine: Upscale Bistro

Atmosphere: Bustling, artsy; jazz combo Thursday through Saturday nights.

Service: Generally excellent.

Prices: Lunch entrees $5 to $12; dinner entrees $10 to $19.

Kid stuff: Only for very sophisticated tots.

Bar: Fully licensed.

Parking: In adjacent lot.

Credit Cards: All major cards accepted.

Reservations:  Easily accessible by wheelchair.

Diana’s rating: With 10 as a must try, this restaurant rates.

Diana Louise Carter eats out anonymously.  Her reviews alternate with Deborah Fineblum Raub’s column, The Dish.